AndroidGamesLinuxMacOsRen'pyVisual NovelWindow

Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Update 3] [Mutt & Jeff]

Download for Windows/ Linux

Download for Mac

Download for Android

Download Android Data

  • swipe down to hide the ui
  • swipe left to roll back
  • swipe right to start skipping of text
  • swipe 2x left&right to open the game menu
  • swipe up&down to toggle a small window with memory usage information
  • longpress the save file thumbnail in the save/load screen to delete this slot

Download Walkthrough

Download Walkthrough & Gallery Mod


  • This mod adds an in-game walkthrough for the important choices in the game Pale Carnations!
  • I’ve added a scene replay gallery unlocker to unlock all gallery scenes.
  • I’ve currently made a few improvements to some of the events in the game so that you will be able to see several missable scenes. Read the full list of improvements below to see all of the changes.


PC: Unzip the mod and put the folder named “game” from the mod in your “Pale Carnations-Ch. 2 Up 2” folder.
MAC: Unzip the mod -> Right-click your “Pale Carnations” app -> Click “Show Package Contents” -> Open the “Contents” then “Resources” folders -> Hold the Option key and drag the folder named “game” from the mod to the “autorun” folder -> Click merge

You can also mail us at :-

Editor's Rating

Story - 89%
Visual - 91%
Engagement - 87%
Core Loop - 85%


out off 100%

This review is based on author's perspective and actual experience may differ on individual's own preferences.

User Rating: 4.25 ( 110 votes)

Related Articles


  1. AMAZING game, I’m just gonna start the second event and this game has me hooked.
    On top of that: Hanna wearing a “Scenes From A Memory” Dream Theater shirt is cool as fuck !!!
    Great writing, great taste, these devs are good!!

  2. Just finished playing for the first time up until the newest update. Was hesitant at first because the whole “Sex Club” isn’t really my vibe most of the time, but this AVN has just become one of my all time favorites. Incredible characters all around, good music, great animations, the dialogue/writing is good all the way up until Week 3, then it’s just phenomenal.

    I’m simply hooked, can’t wait for more Ronnie.

  3. Rayos que buen juego, no dejen que los tags te desanimen a jugarlo, hasta ahora se puede evitar llegar a ciertos extremos (sobretodo usando walkthrought) pero la historia y los personajes de este juego valen totalmente la pena, esta muy bien escrita, las escenas lewd son sexys y animadas, las decisiones que tomas importan y afectan a la historia y a
    Damn what a great game! don’t let the tags discourage you from playing it, until now you can avoid reaching certain extremes (especially using walkthrought) but the story and the characters of this game are totally worth it, it is very well written, the lewd scenes are sexy and animated, the decisions you make matter and affect the story and characters. I only hope that the NTR can continue to be avoided, or at least that you can “choose” which of the “Carnations” you can save from falling into it… Although I would also settle for only with Mina’s path, that woman is too perfect, few times a character has made me fall in love like her

  4. To play this version o n android you must do these after downloading the game and it’s data:
    1. install the the game file
    2. open the game and exit. This will make a folder by the name of “palecarnations.v43” in Documents> RenPy_Saves in the internal storage of your cellphone (search PALE in file manager and you will find it)
    3. There is a folder named game In the palecarnations.v43 folder, paste the rpa file in it
    4. Enjoy the game

  5. Now the freaking saves don’t work…. AGAIN. Its always something with this dev, but I love the ‘carnations’ so IS IT WORTH ANOTHER START FROM SCRATCH?! Maybe wait for a couple more updates before the pain sets in again.

    1. Can you write a little more information as your post isnt really helpful towards neither the dev or other people who play the VN. I’d suggest at the minimum identifying the system you are using so they at least know which one is buggy. Personally, I run on a windows setup and have had no problems with the current release of the VN. I even ran through the story twice to unlock all scenes.

  6. Ugh, this is happening more often lately… webp files won’t translate resulting in a variety of file not found errors such as this one (leaves me wondering if there is something on my end I could fix?):
    — Full Traceback ————————————————————

    Full traceback:
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 316, in bootstrap
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 578, in main
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 143, in run
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 908, in run_context
    File “Week2Exhibition.rpyc”, line 3673, in script
    File “Week2Exhibition.rpyc”, line 3673, in script
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 708, in execute
    renpy.exports.say(who, what, *args, **kwargs)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 1345, in say
    who(what, *args, **kwargs)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 1142, in __call__
    self.do_display(who, what, cb_args=self.cb_args, **display_args)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 842, in do_display
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 591, in display_say
    rv = renpy.ui.interact(mouse=’say’, type=type, roll_forward=roll_forward)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\”, line 297, in interact
    rv =, **kwargs)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 2702, in interact
    repeat, rv = self.interact_core(preloads=preloads, trans_pause=trans_pause, **kwargs)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 3194, in interact_core
    self.draw_screen(root_widget, fullscreen_video, (not fullscreen_video) or video_frame_drawn)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 2094, in draw_screen
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 490, in renpy.display.render.render_screen (gen\renpy.display.render.c:6805)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 722, in render
    surf = render(child, width, height, cst, cat)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 722, in render
    surf = render(child, width, height, cst, cat)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 722, in render
    surf = render(child, width, height, cst, cat)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 675, in render
    child = renpy.display.render.render(self.child, w, h, st, at)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 722, in render
    surf = render(child, width, height, cst, cat)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 1127, in render
    st, at)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\display\”, line 883, in render
    surf = render(d, rw, height – y, cst, cat)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 166, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:4075)
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “accelerator.pyx”, line 110, in renpy.display.accelerator.transform_render
    File “renpy/display/render.pyx”, line 259, in renpy.display.render.render (gen\renpy.display.render.c:3520)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\text\”, line 1996, in render
    virtual_layout = Layout(self, width, height, renders, drawable_res=False, size_only=True)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\text\”, line 626, in __init__
    glyphs = ts.glyphs(s, self)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\text\”, line 242, in glyphs
    fo = font.get_font(self.font, self.size, self.bold, self.italic, 0, self.antialias, self.vertical, self.hinting, layout.oversample)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\text\”, line 699, in get_font
    face = load_face(fn)
    File “D:\AVN\PaleCarnations-Ch4Up2-pc\renpy\text\”, line 642, in load_face
    rv = ftfont.FTFace(font_file, index, orig_fn) # @UndefinedVariable
    File “ftfont.pyx”, line 183, in renpy.text.ftfont.FTFace.__init__
    FreetypeError: 2: unknown file format

  7. a cut above the rest, this story is intricate and devious. subtle and mysterious. the animation is fucking superb. and I fucking HATE IT when i get to the end of the current versions! this game puts 98% of everything on this site to shame.

  8. This vn is nice, and its incredibly hard to get ntr, its like you actually have to try to get it. I like it so far.

  9. Fuck you, NTR lovers.

    All these faggoty cucks should be hung by a rope and then beat with a bat full of jagged rusty nails as they swing and gasp for air.

  10. There seems to be an issue with the trigger for the carnations punishment in week 3 which unlocks all of the scenes when you end up in a tie for week two’s event leading to all three of them taking part in the punishment. Instead of unlocking just one scene in the memories section, you unlock all four scenes.

  11. I downloaded this once when it was less farther along, a long time ago. Have to say off the bat three things make me wary to download again.

    1) The NTR should ALWAYS be AVOIDABLE (If it must be there at all… and like many I prefer not)

    2) No Harem tag. [You are meant to pursue MULTIPLE women; don’t try to force the player to keep just one]

    3) No pregnancy tag. You do know what the real thrill of a creampie is to most people; right?
    It’s only got half as much draw as it does to most players who like it at all because BIOLOGICAL IMPERATIVE!
    The risk of it, while being fully aware is what makes it so hot when she ignores her base fears and begs for it done.

    Aside from that, there’s a lot of uncertainty about the MC’s eventual fate. How far he’s willing to, or can go.
    The girls all force him to grind events just to get anywhere. So yeah. Add in those three things and maybe…
    MAYBE. I might consider downloading again. Not that I think you’ll give a toss if I do, mind. It would just be nice.
    I’d consider it confirmation our work – like your own – is going to be rewarded at the end of the day. Anyway…

    Toodles. I gotta find me a white sports coat. Now, how many of you get that reference?
    What; we do at least get enough pink that it doesn’t have to be about carnations.

    1. I can kind of agree with the NTR issue but this VN is focused on depravity so certain things will happen if the MC wants them to or not of which only seems to be 2 scenes thus far that cant be avoided, the strap op scene with Kathleen and Veronica and the drug induced 3 way with the carnations. The scenes with Killian are avoidable through the choices picked. I’m also expecting a future scene to appear later where the 3 carnations are tied to wooden horses and all the male spectators get their chance to unload in each of them since there were images of that happening to the previous contestants.

      As for pregnancy, the story is set over a specific time period so the usual time frame required for a pregnancy wouldn’t come to fruition to suit your tastes. Perhaps if the developer added something so you could have fun with the pregnant prostitute that could help if you have a fetish for lactation. I also agree with your definition of the thrill of creampie’s, but if you were female and going to a gentlemen’s club to get drilled surely you’d take precautions to avoid getting pregnant by a random guy, I know I would if I was in that position.

    2. sorry but no you are not meant to pursue multiple woman if you were there would be a harem tag you can pursue multiple if you so choose but your not meant to since that’s not the point behind this AVN also if you have that big of a lady boner for that harem easy just click the harem tag ta da simple

    3. you do get that adding more tags means more work right? most of these developers are a 1-2 man group, the more tags say harem or pregnancy for example means that the developers have to come up with a whole new path. 1 path for hana 1 path for mina 1 path for harem 1 path this girl is pregnant 1 path incest yada yada u get the point, then each update will take even longer to publish and then ppl will start bitching about that too. Its just a pain in the ass. Just let the developers do their thing and if u like it play it if not dont, its legit free to play, dont shit on a game that is GOOD just because its not perfect for ur taste. Dont get me wrong I also like harem but still u gotta understand just how much work adding that would affect the work load, heck it might even lower the quality of the story if they focus too much on that stuff.

  12. This is a a really excellent AVN. It has a really well written main character and all the main girls and side characters too. Also the renders for the main girls are excellent. The facial expressions are some of the best I have seen in a AVN. There’s also a nice bit of replayabilty which will likely increase as the game develops more. overall i really enjoyed it and i would highly recommend it.

  13. Hana and Mina are some of the most loveable characters I’ve ever read in a VN. Their personalities, storylines and detailed facial expressions just so remarkable. 10/10.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button